COMPLETE / INDEPENDENTLY VERIFIED / PHYSICAL OWNERSHIP-ENERGETICS GAP / REPLAN
The owner authorized proceeding with R13's proposed LOCAL_MECHANOCHEMICAL_REACTION_AFFINITY_FEASIBILITY_GATE, independent verification, preservation and project-record synchronization on 2026-10-17. This supersedes the prior proposal-only authorization marker for this feasibility audit; it does not authorize feedback implementation or biological campaigns.
Directive: DC-M4-REACTION-ARCHITECTURE-FEASIBILITY-GATE-001. Local directive: D-20261017-dcm4-reaction-architecture-feasibility. Start exactly at R13 final governance head 74dfbf9a12fc9cdafcc72c3080150a7b9c04be90, CI 39015335353 PASS, artifact sha256:adedc07c15c48b90db9901a68ec6f42afc55d67ac5954f0916ade55f0013b719, manifest 13/13. DC-M4-R13 — Geometry-to-Polarity Intra-Operator Causal Decomposition Gate remains reaction-mediated damping in 30/30 exact states, uncorrected.
Determine whether an already-existing local membrane/cortical mechanical state and existing laws support a physically owned, finite-energy active↔inactive conversion bias. Return one supported architecture contract only if ownership and energetics close; otherwise return a precise missing-state/energetics gap. No invented tension, flow, coefficient, signed affinity or observer-to-causal-state substitution.
Audit source ownership, units and active call graph, including existing other-domain thermodynamic models and strain-dependent structural chemistry. Independently derive the fixed-amount reaction geometry susceptibility and distinguish it from full-update feedback. Distinguish local state, force, kinetic rate ratio, operational A/W cost and conversion-conjugate work. Any supported proposal must account for signed conversion work, material/energy positivity, finite funding, atomicity, persistence/remesh/fission ownership, locality and route-OFF parity. Missing required ownership is a valid completed negative feasibility result, not permission to improvise a law.
Use a separate read-only analyst and independent reviewer, parent algebra/source/preservation checks, exact-head audit CI and artifact bindings. The architect bridge remains unavailable; no bridge dispatch or acceptance claim. No new physical/simulation campaign is required to identify a source-architecture gap.
Isolated checkout /home/sketch/Projects/digital_cell-reaction-feasibility, branch codex/dc-m4-reaction-architecture-feasibility. Existing checkouts, histories and PR #44/#45 remain untouched. Preserve amount/current-length concentration physics, R3 coefficients/diffusion, R4 force/cost, R10 diagnostic scope, mechanics and ecology. No feedback code, new state, parameter tuning, morphogenesis, reproduction, population/selection, reversal, final integration or automatic successor.
Classification: LOCAL_REACTION_COUPLING_PHYSICAL_OWNERSHIP_OR_ENERGETICS_GAP. A distinct read-only analyst and independent reviewer agree that the accepted R3/R4 MaterialMesh path does not supply a complete existing-owner mechanical conversion-affinity contract. Existing strain, material structure, pressure and funded forces are real. Missing are a conversion-associated mechanical work/free-energy relation, common fuel/energy-unit ownership, and a signed constitutive rate relation. This is a completed negative feasibility result, not a claim that mechanosensing is impossible or that new persistent state is necessary.
The exact frozen unclipped amount-rate is J=k0*b-kd*a+(kf*a*a*b-kq*a*a*a)/L², with fixed-amount derivative partial_L J=-2*a*a*(kf*b-kq*a)/L³. Independent exact sparse-polynomial expansion/differentiation checks pass. The derivative applies only at an unclipped fixed-amount substep; it is not the full-update feedback sign.
Native polarity spending is 0.5 × |net transfer|, with finite A funding/equal W credit. At illustrative algebraic amounts a=L=1,b=11/101, the frozen positive forward and backward terms both equal 11/100, while net transfer/charge are zero. This distinguishes net accounting from gross turnover and does not invalidate the adopted operational cost model. A kinetic log-ratio alone does not supply mechanical thermodynamics.
The audit covers eight candidate classes: material geometry/strain, passive stretch, bending, pressure, R4/R10 forces, contact/observer work, regulatory plasticity, and structural/membrane chemistry. Four real other-domain models—Cartesian phi free energy, precursor/surface exchange affinity, reduced theta/P adsorption, and grid-interface membrane transport—are acknowledged but have no adopted mapping into active/inactive polarity conversion. No existing coefficient or model is repurposed.
Exactly one bounded consequence is returned: a future conversion-work ownership contract must identify a supported local conversion extent and either consistent cross-energy/mechanical counterpart or an explicitly driven finite-fuel/work cycle, plus signed rate response, positivity/conservation, no double counting, locality, atomic rejection, persistence/remesh/fission ownership and route-OFF parity. It is a missing contract requirement, not an implemented formula or automatic successor. R9's failed tensile activation multiplier and R13's reaction-damping attribution remain preserved.
The parent checker binds 16 frozen source files and 28 repository evidence files, exact algebra, append-only histories and new structured records. First CI 39052366092 passed checks but its ZIP was independently rejected because the uploader omitted eight hidden manifest-bound governance/workflow files. That archive/rejection is preserved; the bounded uploader setting was corrected and exact-head publication is being reverified. The final accepted head/CI/ZIP will supersede this packaging attempt below. No new scientific executable or simulation campaign is part of this source-only audit. Draft PR #46 contains the auditable result.
Final head f4397836c4703bcae8b14ebc01c99a8abe4af420 passed exact-head audit CI 39052453110. Artifact ID 12108053159, name dc-m4-reaction-architecture-feasibility-f4397836c4703bcae8b14ebc01c99a8abe4af420, ZIP sha256:8861f07060210d18c6da1770163db8ed6f372b63a124238ca44b915bee25e8f7.